White paper · Physicians

Transient draft: why your EMR stays the only chart

A scribe that keeps its notes becomes a second patient chart. This paper explains what the tool keeps, for how long, and what happens at the time of transfer.

8 min read
Two-voice conversation · Synthetic voices4:09
Conversation: Transient draft

Two voices walk through the white paper, question by question, for those who prefer to listen.

0:004:09
Read the full conversation

Two-voice conversation generated with synthetic voices from the verified content on this page.

Julie

Many AI scribes keep an indefinite archive of past encounter notes inside their own web dashboard. Why does this white paper warn that doing so creates a shadow patient chart?

Marc

Because a physician or nurse practitioner charting in MYLE, Omnimed, OSCAR, or Cristal-Net already has one certified legal medical record. The moment an external tool stores identifiable clinical notes or audio recordings indefinitely alongside your EMR, you effectively hold a second patient chart—doubling what your clinic has to secure, audit, disclose on access requests, and govern under Québec's Law 25 and Law 5.

Julie

That's why Silenoa built Ephemeral Scribe mode around a transient draft. What does the tool actually hold, and what does it never store?

Marc

First, what never exists in this mode: zero seconds of audio written to disk, and no persistent patient-folders module at all. Even when Whisper assists you on an open EMR tab, it reads the active screen strictly in volatile session RAM without saving any chart copy to a database. The only thing held temporarily is the four-part draft—Subjective, Objective, Assessment, and Plan—just long enough for you to transfer it.

Julie

Walk us through the exact moment of transfer into the EMR once an encounter wraps up.

Marc

You open the patient's encounter in your EMR tab alongside our Chrome extension side panel. One click on Auto-Fill drops Subjective, Objective, Assessment, and Plan straight into their matching boxes—and if your clinic uses a custom EMR layout, each card also has its own one-click copy button.

Julie

Can the Chrome extension ever save or sign the encounter inside the EMR on the physician's behalf?

Marc

Never. That boundary is hard-coded: the extension never clicks Sign or Save. You review the text directly inside your EMR, adjust anything needed, and sign the legal note yourself. As soon as you confirm transfer, the transient draft is purged immediately.

Julie

What happens on a busy morning when a physician prefers to batch-review three or four notes at the end of a clinic block?

Marc

By default, any unpurged draft deletes itself automatically after 48 hours, with a visible countdown timer on every draft card. In workspace settings, you can tighten that window to immediate or 24 hours, or extend it up to a hard ceiling of 30 days—for instance right before a holiday weekend.

Julie

So there is deliberately no 'keep forever' toggle anywhere in Ephemeral Scribe mode?

Marc

None at all. Leaving out an indefinite option guarantees the tool stays a transient scratchpad rather than drifting into a secondary archive. And in a family medicine group or multi-clinician practice, the administrator can lock that retention cap across every seat.

Julie

What if a physician wants to refine one section before sending the draft into MYLE, Omnimed, OSCAR, or Cristal-Net?

Marc

You can edit any of the four cards right inside the transient draft—or ask for a targeted rewrite of a single section—before clicking Auto-Fill. And once the text lands in your EMR boxes, you still have full control to adjust every word before signing the legal encounter.

Julie

And if a patient shares an insurance number out loud, does that sit inside the temporary draft?

Marc

No—RAMQ health-insurance numbers and Social Insurance Numbers are automatically stripped before synthesis, and anti-fabrication rules prevent the AI from inventing vital signs or unspoken clinical findings.

Julie

If a physician or FMG lead is comparing AI scribes this month, what checklist of questions should they bring to every vendor?

Marc

Five straightforward questions cover the whole picture: first, is audio written to disk and deleted later, or processed strictly in volatile RAM? Second, does the draft purge on EMR transfer with a mandatory expiry cap and no 'never' setting? Third, is auto-signing impossible? Fourth, do servers, database, and AI processing stay in Montréal and Canada with zero model training? And fifth, can we validate one-click injection directly inside our actual EMR workflow? The printable vendor checklist is right below on this page.

In short

  • An AI scribe that retains encounter notes and audio indefinitely outside your electronic medical record (EMR) creates a shadow patient chart that must be secured, reconciled, and disclosed.
  • In Ephemeral Scribe Mode, there is no “Patient Charts” module inside Silenoa: your certified EMR (MYLE, Omnimed, OSCAR, or Cristal-Net) remains your sole legal record.
  • Zero audio is ever written to disk (0 h); only an encrypted four-part draft (S, O, A, P) exists long enough to bridge the transfer, deleting itself immediately on confirmation or automatically after 48 hours by default.
  • Draft retention is configurable from immediate up to 30 days maximum, with no “never” setting.
  • The Chrome extension populates each section into the matching box of your open EMR in 1 click, and never clicks “Sign” or “Save” on your behalf.

1. The risk of a second chart

You already maintain one authoritative legal chart. In family medicine clinics, specialty practices, and Family Medicine Groups (FMGs), your certified EMR—whether MYLE, Omnimed, OSCAR, or Cristal-Net—is the single clinical system of record. Lab results, imaging, medication lists, referrals, signed encounter notes, and audit logs all converge there.

How a writing assistant quietly turns into a parallel chart. Many medical scribes store an unlimited history of past encounter notes on their own cloud servers by default, sometimes alongside raw audio recordings or verbatim transcripts. Even when used solely to save typing time, an unpurged scribe database becomes a second patient chart sitting outside your EMR.

Three practical risks of a shadow chart

  1. Clinical version drift between two records: suppose you inject a draft into MYLE, refine your differential diagnosis or adjust a medication dose inside the EMR, and sign the official note. If the external scribe keeps its unedited draft forever, two conflicting accounts of the same visit now exist on two different servers.
  2. Expanded scope during access requests and inspections (Law 25 and Law 5): when a patient submits an access request, or during a review by the Collège des médecins du Québec (CMQ), an insurer, or a coroner, any persistent clinical repository held on your behalf must be accounted for, searched, and potentially disclosed.
  3. Unnecessary privacy exposure: keeping thousands of historical clinical notes inside a tool whose job ended the moment you signed your EMR note multiplies privacy obligations without adding any clinical utility.
Architectural dimensionPersistent-archive scribe (shadow chart)Transient Draft Doctrine (Silenoa)
Patient directoryPermanent patient folders stored outside your EMRZero patient folders or longitudinal directory in this mode
Encounter audioOften saved to disk first and deleted later (or retained)0 h on disk: transcribed in volatile RAM in Montréal and discarded
Note lifespanIndefinite archive by defaultPurged on confirmed EMR transfer or after 48 h by default (30-day cap)
Authoritative recordRisk of mismatch between stored draft and signed EMR entrySingle source of truth: the reviewed note signed inside your EMR
Reading prior clinical contextSyncing or copying chart records onto external serversWhisper reads your open EMR tab in volatile session RAM (0 database writes)

2. What the tool keeps, and for how long

Zero folders, zero audio, one short-lived encrypted draft. In Ephemeral Scribe Mode, Silenoa acts strictly as a clinical writing bridge, never as a parallel repository. Every piece of encounter data follows a bounded, verifiable lifecycle:

Data elementTechnical handlingRetention duration
Patient and clinician voiceStreamed in encrypted chunks into volatile memory (RAM) in Montréal (northamerica-northeast1)0 seconds on disk
RAMQ and SIN numbersAutomatically stripped by a redaction filter prior to draft synthesisNever stored in the draft
EMR screen context read by WhisperRead strictly in volatile session memory from your open EMR tab to answer in-visit clinical questions0 seconds in any database (cleared when the tab closes)
Structured S / O / A / P draftEncrypted at rest (AES-256) in Montréal with a visible expiration countdownDeleted immediately on confirmed transfer, or automatically after 48 h by default

Why 48 hours by default? Clinic days rarely run on a textbook schedule: a pending afternoon lab value, an urgent walk-in interruption, or a late Friday clinic can delay signing a couple of encounters. A 48-hour default ceiling gives you practical breathing room to review and transfer an unfinished draft without allowing forgotten notes to accumulate week after week.

3. What happens at transfer

Consider a fictional encounter: Dr. Martin Tremblay sees Mr. Jean-Luc Roy (a fictional patient in a simulated MYLE encounter) for hypertension follow-up and mechanical right knee pain. Four distinct steps separate automated drafting from medical responsibility.

Step 1: Card-by-card review (S, O, A, P)

As soon as the visit ends, the draft presents four clean cards: Subjective, Objective, Assessment, and Plan (See the guide to reviewing and correcting a SOAP note). Anti-hallucination rules prevent fabricated measurements: if the blood pressure reading spoken aloud was 138/84 mmHg, it appears under Objective; if respiratory rate was never mentioned, nothing is invented.

Step 2: One-click Chrome Auto-Fill into your EMR

Instead of copy-pasting four separate blocks between browser windows, the physician opens the patient's encounter note inside MYLE, Omnimed, OSCAR, or Cristal-Net and opens the Chrome extension's side panel (See the guide to filling your EMR in one click). Clicking Fill EMR once places Subjective, Objective, Assessment, and Plan into their exact EMR boxes, including the automatic traceability footer. For custom EMR layouts, each card also offers a dedicated one-click copy button.

Step 3: Final clinician review and signature inside the EMR

This boundary is deliberate. Signing a clinical note is an act of professional judgment reserved for the physician or nurse practitioner. You read the populated text directly inside your EMR, adjust any wording you wish, and sign using your EMR's native workflow.

Step 4: Immediate draft purge

Once the boxes are populated and you confirm the transfer in the side panel, Silenoa permanently deletes the transient draft from its Montréal database. Before you call the next patient in from the waiting room, your signed note lives exclusively inside your certified EMR.

4. Setting retention

Different medical practices close charts at different cadences. Practitioners—or clinic administrators—can adjust the automatic expiration window inside workspace settings (See the guide to setting draft retention):

  • Immediate on transfer (recommended daily workflow): instant purge as soon as EMR injection is confirmed, paired with a short safety timer (24 h or 48 h) for any draft left open.
  • 24 hours or 48 hours (default): built for full-time family medicine and outpatient clinics closing charts the same day or the next morning.
  • 7 days up to 30 days maximum: helpful for part-time shift schedules, consulting specialists awaiting an external test result before dictating a final consult letter, or weekend coverage.
  • No “never” setting: the retention selector stops at 30 days. Ephemeral Scribe Mode cannot be configured into indefinite storage.

Group and FMG retention governance. In a Multidisciplinary Group or private FMG deployment (5+ clinicians), the designated clinic administrator or privacy officer can enforce a mandatory clinic-wide retention cap (for example, 48 hours across every seat). Every pending draft displays a live countdown badge showing exactly when automatic deletion will occur.

5. Questions to ask any AI scribe

Before adopting any AI scribe in your medical office or FMG, bring this exact due-diligence checklist to every vendor—including us—and review the written answers with your privacy officer (RPRP):

Question to ask the vendorAnswer that prevents a shadow chartHow to verify it during a live demo
1. Is encounter audio ever written to disk?No—0 seconds on disk; transcription runs strictly in volatile RAM.Confirm there is no audio playback button once the encounter ends.
2. How long are draft notes retained?Purged on EMR transfer, with a mandatory short cap (never unlimited).Open the retention settings menu and verify there is no “never” or “forever” option.
3. Do you store a patient directory?Zero persistent patient folders for clinicians charting in an EMR.Inspect the Physicians workspace navigation and verify no longitudinal chart list exists.
4. Where do servers and AI models run?Application servers, database, and AI inference all run in Montréal / Canada.Ask for the exact cloud region identifier (e.g. northamerica-northeast1).
5. Does our clinical data train AI models?Never, backed by contractual Zero Data Retention with the model provider.Verify explicit written commitments in the security brief and terms of service.
6. Can the extension click Sign in my EMR?Never—it fills text fields only; the clinician reviews and signs in the EMR.Watch a live Chrome Auto-Fill into a simulated MYLE or Omnimed form.
7. How are RAMQ/SIN and vitals handled?Automatic RAMQ/SIN redaction and strict prohibition on inventing unstated vitals.Speak a dummy identifier and omit blood pressure during a test encounter to check the output.
8. Can an FMG lock retention across seats?Yes—clinic administrators can enforce a group-wide maximum retention policy.Review the group admin governance controls with your privacy officer.

To go deeper, read our Security and hosting brief and our white paper on Consent and AI scribes.

Try it with your own encounters

The Ephemeral Scribe mode is free to try for 14 days, with no commitment.

Start the free trial →