White paper

Consent and AI scribes: what to tell the person in front of you

Before opening the microphone, you need the person's agreement. This paper covers the points to tell them, what to do if they refuse, and how to keep a record of it.

7 min read
Two-voice conversation · Synthetic voices2:56
Conversation: Consent and AI scribes

Two voices walk through the white paper, question by question, for those who prefer to listen.

0:002:56
Read the full conversation

Two-voice conversation generated with synthetic voices from the verified content on this page.

Julie

Clinicians starting out with an AI scribe often share the same practical concern: how do you ask the person across from you for consent without making the first minute of the visit feel stiff or technical?

Marc

By keeping it warm, plain, and under fifteen seconds. Whether you're seeing a medical patient or a client in psychology, physiotherapy, chiropractic, occupational therapy, speech-language pathology, osteopathy, or dietetics, people want to know three clear things: a tool is helping draft the note so you can focus on them, no audio recording is kept, and you personally review and sign everything.

Julie

What does that sound like word for word using the built-in reminder inside Silenoa?

Marc

Here is natural phrasing you can say in one breath: 'So I can focus fully on our conversation instead of typing on my screen, I use a Québec clinical assistant that drafts my note while we talk. No audio recording is saved, I review every word myself before signing, and I can pause it anytime. Are you comfortable with that?'

Julie

How does the interface make sure a busy clinician never opens the microphone by accident before asking?

Marc

The microphone stays hard-locked until you tick the informed verbal consent box on screen. And once the encounter is underway, a single click pauses listening immediately—during a physical exam, for instance, or whenever someone wants to share something off the transcript.

Julie

What if the patient or client says no, or seems hesitant?

Marc

Refusal has to feel completely effortless and respected. If someone prefers not to use it, you simply leave the microphone closed and carry on the visit with your usual note-taking, with zero impact on their care.

Julie

When they do agree, how is that consent documented in the chart?

Marc

Every assisted draft or progress note in Silenoa automatically includes a concise traceability footer stating that informed verbal consent was obtained, AI-assisted drafting was used without storing audio, and the note was reviewed and validated by the signing clinician.

Julie

Does anything change during a video telehealth session, or when a family member joins the appointment?

Marc

The principle is identical, with one extra courtesy: in a remote video session or when a parent, partner, or caregiver is in the room, make sure everyone taking part in the conversation hears the fifteen-second explanation and agrees before you unlock the microphone.

Julie

How should clinicians in Québec situate this within their regulatory obligations?

Marc

These operational safeguards are designed to support your day-to-day alignment with Law 25, Law 5, CMQ guidance, and allied-health college charting standards: upfront verbal consent, zero stored audio, Montréal hosting, automatic RAMQ and Social Insurance Number stripping, mandatory human review, and traceability footers. Because this paper is practical operational guidance rather than legal advice, we always encourage reviewing your clinic's exact wording with your professional order or privacy officer. You can read and print the full templates right below.

In short

  • Before activating an AI scribe during a medical visit or clinical session, the practitioner obtains free and informed verbal consent from the person in front of them.
  • In Silenoa, the microphone remains locked until the informed consent checkbox is ticked, and a 1-click pause button suspends capture during physical examinations.
  • A built-in 15-second reminder displays the four plain-language points to share: how the tool helps draft the note, zero saved audio (0 h), Montréal hosting, and the freedom to decline.
  • If the person declines, the encounter proceeds normally with the microphone closed and zero impact on the quality or duration of care.
  • Every generated note includes an automatic traceability footer documenting informed verbal consent, AI-assisted drafting, and full review by the signing clinician.

1. Why ask for agreement

Clinical trust comes first. Whether someone is seeing a family physician, nurse practitioner, psychologist, physiotherapist, chiropractor, osteopath, occupational therapist, speech-language pathologist, or dietitian, they expect a confidential conversation with a trusted clinician. Introducing an ambient writing tool without a clear, upfront explanation erodes trust—even when the underlying security architecture is sound.

What makes verbal consent genuinely informed. Asking “Is it okay if I use my AI tool?” is too vague on its own: patients and clients naturally wonder whether a voice recording is being archived, where their words travel, or whether software is making clinical decisions. Informed verbal agreement rests on four straightforward facts:

  1. What the tool does: it helps structure my clinical note while we talk so I can focus on you instead of typing at my screen.
  2. What happens to your voice: zero audio recording is ever saved on disk (0 h); speech is converted in volatile memory on servers in Montréal and immediately discarded.
  3. Who decides and signs: I personally review, edit, and sign the note—the tool never makes a medical or clinical decision.
  4. Complete freedom to say no: you can decline right now, or ask me to pause at any point, and I will write my notes myself as usual.

Built-in safeguards inside Silenoa. So that consent is never forgotten during a busy clinic day, Silenoa embeds two safeguards directly into the encounter screen (See the guide to starting an encounter):

  • Hard-locked microphone by default: audio capture cannot start until you tick the informed verbal consent confirmation box.
  • One-click pause during physical exams: when moving to auscultation, orthopedic or osteopathic palpation, or whenever an accompanying family member speaks about matters outside the chart, a single click pauses capture and resumes only when you choose.

2. The points to say, in 15 seconds

When you open a new encounter or session, Silenoa displays a concise visual prompt. There is no legalese to read aloud—fifteen seconds in warm, everyday language covers everything the person needs to decide. Below are three word-for-word scripts you can use as written or adapt to your natural voice.

Script for physicians and nurse practitioners with an EMR (Ephemeral Scribe Mode)

Script for allied health clinicians and private clinics (Longitudinal Clinical Mode)

Tailored for psychologists, chiropractors, physiotherapists, osteopaths, occupational therapists, speech-language pathologists, and dietitians:

Script for remote video telehealth sessions

When holding a remote session inside the built-in encrypted video room (See the guide to holding a video session), include a brief check on privacy at both ends:

Prompt shown in the 15-second reminderWhat the person clearly understands
1. Note-drafting assistanceMy clinician is listening to me directly; the tool only prepares a written draft.
2. Zero stored audio (0 h)My voice is never archived in a recording library.
3. Montréal hosting & clinician reviewMy health information stays in Québec, and my practitioner verifies and signs every word.
4. Freedom to decline or pauseSaying no is welcome, respected immediately, and never affects my care.

3. If the person refuses

Consent is meaningful only when declining feels effortless. Some patients or clients—during an initial psychotherapy intake, a sensitive medical concern, or simply out of personal preference—prefer that no transcription tool be used.

Four calm steps when someone declines

  1. Welcome the choice warmly: reply simply, “Of course, no problem at all—I'll write my notes myself,” without asking them to explain why.
  2. Leave the consent box unticked: keep the microphone locked inside Silenoa so zero audio ever enters the workspace.
  3. Carry on the visit normally: type your note directly into your EMR or, in Longitudinal Clinical Mode, write and sign your progress note manually inside the client's chart.
  4. Honour mid-session pauses immediately: if someone initially agreed and later says, “I'd rather keep this part off the tool,” click Pause (or end capture) in one click and record only clinically necessary facts manually.

4. Keeping a record of agreement

Why written traceability matters months later. During a professional college inspection or chart audit long after a visit, verbal consent is only verifiable if the chart records how the note was produced and who validated it.

Automatic traceability footer. Whenever a note is generated in Silenoa after confirming verbal consent, a concise traceability footer is automatically appended to the bottom of the draft injected into your EMR or signed inside the client chart:

In Longitudinal Clinical Mode (for instance when Ms. Sophie Lavoie, a fictional physiotherapist, signs a rehabilitation progress note), both the consent confirmation timestamp and the cryptographic signature lock are written permanently to the chart's immutable Law 5 audit log (See the guide to signing a session and adding an addendum). When a note is typed manually without activating the microphone, no AI scribe footer is attached.

5. The framework in Québec

In Québec, using an AI scribe in clinical practice sits at the intersection of three complementary frameworks that every clinic, practitioner, and FMG should review alongside their privacy officer (RPRP) and professional college:

  1. Québec Law 25 (Act to modernize legislative provisions as regards the protection of personal information): requires clear transparency at the point of collection whenever technology processes personal information, designated RPRP oversight, a Privacy Impact Assessment (PIA / ÉFVP) proportionate to the tool, and respect for access and rectification rights.
  2. Québec Law 5 (Act respecting health and social services information): governs the protection, data minimisation, residency governance, and tamper-evident audit logging of views, creations, signatures, and disclosures of health information.
  3. Guidelines of the Collège des médecins du Québec (CMQ) and Québec professional colleges (OPQ, OCQ, OPPQ, OEQ, OOAQ, ODTQ): while each regulatory college sets profession-specific charting standards, all share four foundational duties: obtaining free and informed consent prior to capture, upholding professional secrecy, never delegating clinical judgment to software, and thoroughly reviewing every note before signing.
Practical expectation in QuébecBuilt-in safeguard in Silenoa
Inform the person prior to capture15-second on-screen prompt and hard-locked microphone until verbal consent is ticked
Minimise captured information0 h disk audio, automatic RAMQ / SIN redaction, and 1-click physical exam pause
Keep health data in Québec / CanadaServers, database, and AI processing hosted in Montréal (northamerica-northeast1) under Zero Data Retention
Preserve clinician accountabilityNever auto-signs in your EMR; immutable human signatures and dated addenda in longitudinal charts
Document technological assistanceAutomatic traceability footer on every note plus Law 5 audit logging

We encourage every practitioner and clinic manager to validate their intake phrasing and charting workflow with their own professional college and privacy officer. For full architectural details, read our Security and hosting brief and our white paper on the Transient draft.

Two clinical modes — 14-day free trial

Physicians with an EMR or clinics in longitudinal care: choose your mode and start your 14-day free trial, with no commitment.

Choose my mode →